Procurement glossary / P

Price Variation Formula

A formula to adjust pricing in the future based upon relating changes in cost elements to independent indices. When negotiating long-term pricing arrangements, each party faces risk and uncertainty. The risk is that, if the parties agree a fixed price for an extended period of time, the buyer may pay more or less than the market price prevailing in the future, and the seller may make more or less profit than they might have done if the pricing was subject to a ‘rise and fall’ clause. The uncertainty comes from agreeing a rise and fall clause, as each party has no knowledge of what future pricing may be, so cannot anticipate costs and revenue. As an alternative to a fixed price or a rise and fall clause, the parties may agree a price variation formula. The parties identify the key variable cost elements in the supplier’s cost structure, the proportion of the total selling price represented by each cost element, and the most appropriate index which can be used to assess future changes in the cost element. For example, labour and material costs are typically included, while overheads and profit are typically excluded. The values are baselined at contract start and then reviewed periodically to assess changes in the published indices, in order to gauge whether a change in pricing is warranted and, if so, in what direction and by how much. See also Logic and Price.

In short

A price variation formula changes a contract price at set intervals by applying the movement in published indices to the parts of the price exposed to cost changes.

How a price variation formula works

A common form is: New price = Base price x (F + L x L1/L0 + M x M1/M0).

  • F is the fixed share that does not move, such as overhead and profit. L and M are the labour and materials shares. F, L and M add up to 1.
  • L0 and M0 are index values at the base date, often shortly before tenders close. L1 and M1 are the latest values at the review date.

Example: a $100 price with F = 0.2, L = 0.5 and M = 0.3. If the labour index rises 4% and the materials index 10%, the new price is 100 x (0.2 + 0.52 + 0.33) = $105.

Rise and fall clauses in contracts

In practice, "rise and fall clause" is used for most clauses that adjust price for cost changes, including formula clauses. The WA Department of Finance, for example, applies rise and fall to standard non-residential building contracts expected to run longer than 26 weeks. Each progress payment is adjusted by 95% of the movement in the ABS producer price index for non-residential building construction in Western Australia, measured from the index published 14 days before tenders close. Internationally, FIDIC 2017 contracts have an optional cost adjustment at Sub-Clause 13.7, and NEC4 has secondary Option X1 for inflation.

Drafting points for buyers

  • Pick indices that track the supplier's real costs, such as the ABS Wage Price Index or Producer Price Indexes.
  • Set the base date, review frequency and which index release applies.
  • Decide on thresholds, caps or floors, and make adjustments work both ways.
  • Exclude work already paid at actual cost or current prices.
  • Provide for an index being renamed, rebased or discontinued, as the ABS advises.

Help with price variation

Comprara helps buyers set and test price adjustment terms through its purchase negotiations and auctions service.

Put the term to work

Definitions are the easy part. Talk to us about applying them in your procurement function.

Discuss your procurement priorities